TSC Chairman Dismisses Viral Interview Scores, Defends Appointment of CEO Cheptumo Ayabei
NAIROBI, November 17, 2026: The Teachers Service Commission (TSC) has moved to quell a growing public storm over the appointment of its new Chief Executive Officer, dismissing a viral document that purported to show the winning candidate scored far below his rivals.
In a press statement issued today, Commission Chairman Dr. Jamleck Muturi John defended the process that led to the appointment of CPA Cheptumo Ayabei as Commission Secretary/CEO, describing it as transparent, accountable and verifiable.
The statement was meant to clear the air after a document claiming to contain the interview scores of the five shortlisted candidates circulated widely online.
The viral claim
According to the document, Robert Odette topped the interviews with 96 per cent. Mr. Ayabei, the eventual appointee, was allegedly placed fourth with 57 per cent.
The claim spread quickly on social media and triggered intense debate over whether the highest scorer had been passed over in favour of an insider.
The Commission came out strongly to dismiss the purported score sheet. It maintained that the recruitment was conducted strictly in accordance with the law and the constitutional principles that govern appointments in public service.
“Transparent, accountable and verifiable”
Dr. Muturi assured teachers and the general public that the recruitment had been carried out in a transparent, accountable and verifiable manner.
He said the Commissioners had displayed high standards of professionalism, integrity, independence and patience throughout a process that stretched over more than a year and was repeatedly interrupted by litigation.
He said the Commission was guided by the national values and principles of governance in Article 10 of the Constitution, the values and principles of public service in Article 232, and the doctrines of equality and non-discrimination in Article 27. Those provisions require appointments to be anchored on fair competition and merit.
The Commission’s position, in essence, is that the interview that produced Mr. Ayabei’s appointment was the culmination of a process open to public scrutiny at each stage, and that the circulating score sheet does not reflect it.
A recruitment process dogged by court battles
The statement also sheds light on why the recruitment took so long, a delay that has fuelled public interest in the outcome.
The office of Commission Secretary/CEO fell vacant on July 1, 2025, after the term of Dr. Nancy Njeri Macharia expired on June 30, 2025.
The Commission had started the recruitment on May 6, 2025, advertising the vacancy in national dailies and on its website and social media platforms.
Barely twenty days later, the Commission was served with a court order dated May 25, 2025, from the Employment and Labour Relations Court in Mombasa in Petition No. 015 of 2025, Thomas Mosomi Oyugi v. Teachers Service Commission & 3 Others.
The order restrained the Commission from proceeding with the recruitment pending determination of the petitioner’s application. The Commission said it complied fully and suspended the exercise.
On January 29, 2026, the court dismissed the application and directed the Commission to resume from where it had stopped.
Just days later, on February 3, 2026, the Commission was served with another order, this time from the High Court in Kiambu in Petition No. 006 of 2026, Simon Kariu Kimaita v. Teachers Service Commission & 3 Others. That order again restrained it from proceeding.
The High Court delivered its judgment on September 17, 2026, directing the Commission to begin the recruitment afresh. The Commission re-advertised the position on September 29, 2026, in compliance.
From 124 applicants to five
When the advertisement closed on October 30, 2026, the Commission had received 124 applications. After evaluating them against the prescribed qualifications and requirements, it shortlisted five candidates for interviews.
The Commission said it published the names of all applicants, together with those of the shortlisted candidates, in the dailies and on the TSC website on November 3, 2026.
It presented the move as evidence of its commitment to openness, and as a way of allowing the public to follow the process and raise concerns before the interviews.
The interviews were held on November 16, 2026. According to the statement, Mr. Ayabei emerged the best among the five shortlisted candidates and was appointed effective the same day. The statement announcing the appointment came a day later, on November 17.
Who is Cheptumo Ayabei?
The Commission used the statement to outline the career of the new CEO, whom it described as a product of the institution he will now lead.
Mr. Ayabei joined the TSC in 1999 as a Finance Officer. He rose to Director Finance in 2011 and Director Finance and Accounts in 2015.
The Commission attributes his progression to his work ethic, exemplary performance, professionalism, dedication to duty and positive attitude.
His career at the Commission spans more than 27 years, and the statement says he has been part of its top leadership team for 19 years.
The Commission credits him with prudent financial management that earned it unqualified financial statements for three consecutive years, in line with the Government’s zero-fault audit principle for public entities.
The executive profile released with the statement gives the audit opinions for 2022/2023 and 2023/2024 as examples and says they strengthened the institution’s credibility with Parliament and the National Treasury.
Academic and professional credentials
According to the profile, Mr. Ayabei holds an MSc in Banking and Finance from the University of Stirling in the United Kingdom (1997) and a Bachelor of Education (Arts) from Kenyatta University (1990).
He is a Certified Public Accountant of Kenya (ICPAK, 2005), and holds certificates in public finance and accounting from the University of Strathclyde in Scotland (1999) and the University of Connecticut in the United States (2003).
His executive development includes a course in financial inclusion at the Harvard Kennedy School (2020), a leadership programme with Public Administration International in London (2019), and a financial risk management course with RIPA International in London (2010).
The profile says he has also completed more than 20 high-level programmes in leadership, finance, audit, procurement, governance and performance management.
He is a member in good standing of ICPAK and the Institute of Internal Auditors of Kenya. In 2024 he was awarded the Order of the Grand Warrior of Kenya (OGW). He has also received a commendation from ICPAK and several internal TSC commendations.
The track record the Commission is pointing to
The profile lists a series of achievements that the Commission says underpin the appointment:
Scale leadership: He oversaw growth of the TSC budget from KES 150 billion to KES 425.6 billion, and of the teacher workforce from about 200,000 to 467,000, which the Commission says more than doubled national service-delivery capacity.
Revenue innovation: He led initiatives that nearly tripled Appropriation-in-Aid revenue, from KES 200 million to KES 998 million, through resource mobilisation.
Systems transformation: He led the implementation of IFMIS and INFOMIX-based systems, improving accuracy, efficiency, transparency and real-time financial analysis and reporting.
Capital projects: He mobilised KES 900 million for construction of the TSC headquarters, which the Commission says yields annual rent savings of up to KES 150 million.
Development financing: He negotiated and secured more than KES 900 million for flagship Vision 2030 projects, and KES 52 million from the World Bank to support digital literacy for about 40,000 teachers and the development of TPAD 1.0.
Acting CEO: He has on multiple occasions been entrusted with full Acting CEO responsibilities, providing strategic direction and operational continuity.
Why the controversy matters
The TSC is one of the most consequential public institutions in the country. It manages a workforce of hundreds of thousands of teachers, handles recruitment, promotion, discipline and payroll, and administers a budget running into hundreds of billions of shillings.
Its chief executive is therefore among the most closely watched appointments in the public service, and any suggestion that merit was sidelined is bound to provoke a strong reaction.
The viral document landed in an already charged environment. The recruitment had dragged on for well over a year, been halted twice by the courts, and was finally restarted afresh.
In that context, a leaked scoreboard showing an outsider far ahead of an insider found a receptive audience online, with many Kenyans questioning whether the process had been fair.
The Commission’s response rests on three pillars. First, it has stressed the lawfulness of the process, which was conducted under Articles 10, 232 and 27 of the Constitution and section 16 of the TSC Act.
Second, it has stressed openness, noting that the names of all applicants and shortlisted candidates were published in advance.
Third, it has stressed that the appointee is a seasoned professional with an extensive record at the institution.
What happens next
Mr. Ayabei takes over a Commission that has been without a substantive CEO since July 2025. His in-tray includes teacher staffing, payroll and pension pressures, and the continued digitisation of teacher management systems.
The new CEO will also need to win the confidence of a profession that has sometimes had a fractious relationship with the employer.
Whether the Commission’s rebuttal puts the matter to rest remains to be seen. In the age of social media, a viral claim can travel faster than a formal correction, and public trust in the process may depend on how convincingly the Commission can answer questions about how the interviews were conducted and scored.
For now, the Commission has put its position on record: the process was lawful, merit-based and transparent, and the person it chose is, in its words, the best candidate among those interviewed.
